Power

NHS staff snooped on patient records 3,029 times – is yours safe?

NHS staff accessing patient records without reason: 3,029 cases at 79 trusts in five years, a regulator deadline and what it means for your medical record.

NHS staff in England inappropriately accessed patient records more than 3,000 times in five years, according to a Press Association analysis published on Wednesday 18 November. The figures, gathered through Freedom of Information requests, arrive days before a regulator’s deadline for health service bosses to vouch personally for their safeguards, and after a run of cases in which staff looked up the records of victims of some of the country’s most notorious tragedies. It is why “NHS staff accessing patient records” and “medical record” have been trending.

Hospital computer screen at night, illustrating the story of NHS staff accessing patient records without a reason

What did the investigation find?

PA sent requests to 143 acute hospital and ambulance trusts in England. Of those, 79 provided exact figures for 2021/22 to 2025/26, recording 3,029 incidents of staff inappropriately accessing patient records. The true total is almost certainly higher: some trusts reported “fewer than five” incidents in a given year to avoid identifying individuals, and many trusts did not give precise numbers at all. Some trusts said their figures included staff looking at their own records, and others said investigation showed a number of cases had a legitimate operational reason.

The trusts with the most incidents over the period were:

  • University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay: 242
  • West Suffolk: 213
  • Northumbria Healthcare: 195

Anna Telfer, chief nursing officer at Morecambe Bay, said the trust has a “zero-tolerance approach” to breaches. Northumbria said a monthly access-monitoring system it introduced in 2024 has reduced incidents, a reminder that higher numbers can partly reflect better detection.

Which cases prompted the outcry?

The statistics might have passed quietly were it not for the cases behind them. According to PA, dozens of health workers looked at the records of victims of the 2024 Southport attack, in which three girls were killed. At Nottingham University Hospitals, 11 staff were dismissed and 14 faced other action after accessing the records of Barnaby Webber, Grace O’Malley-Kumar and Ian Coates, who were killed by Valdo Calocane in 2023.

Around 40 hospital staff viewed the records of a three-year-old boy injured in a crocodile enclosure incident in Cambridgeshire in June. At Yorkshire Ambulance Service, two workers were believed to have accessed, or tried to access, the records of William Chapman, who was killed by a tiger at Yorkshire Wildlife Park. And at East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation Trust, 10 staff were suspended or removed from duty after a possible breach involving the records of three-year-old Noah Woods, who was found dead in a lake in Brantham, Suffolk. Families affected have signed a letter describing the misuse as a “flagrant abuse of power” with “devastating effects”.

What has the regulator done?

On Thursday 12 November, Paul Arnold, chief executive of the Information Commissioner’s Office, wrote to more than 200 of the UK’s most senior health service leaders. They have until 27 November to confirm they are personally satisfied that their organisation’s safeguards work in practice, covering access controls, monitoring, training and consistent action when things go wrong. Organisations whose safeguards have not been reviewed in the past six months are expected to complete a review within three months, Local Government Lawyer reported.

The ICO says it has received more than 300 reports this year of staff looking at records without a legitimate reason. “Accessing someone’s health records without a legitimate reason isn’t harmless curiosity,” Mr Arnold said, describing the problem as “fundamentally a question of leadership and culture”.

Can NHS staff be sacked or prosecuted?

Yes. In September NHS England told trusts to suspend immediately any member of staff suspected of accessing records without good reason and to cut off their system access while the facts are established. Sir Jim Mackey, NHS England’s chief executive, called the latest figures “extremely worrying” and said the NHS “will not tolerate this behaviour”.

Unlawfully obtaining personal data is a criminal offence under section 170 of the Data Protection Act 2018, and the ICO can prosecute individuals. Coverage of NHS England’s earlier guidance noted that 16 healthcare staff have been prosecuted in the last decade. Professional regulators can also take action against clinicians’ registration.

What can patients do?

Rachel Power, chief executive of the Patients Association, said: “Cases like these erode trust, not only in the trust involved but in the wider NHS.” Patients, she argued, should be able to expect that inappropriate access will be detected quickly and that they will be told promptly if their confidentiality is breached. In practical terms:

  • You can make a subject access request to your GP practice or hospital trust for your records, and ask about who has accessed them.
  • If you believe your record has been viewed without reason, raise it with the organisation’s data protection officer, who must investigate.
  • If you are unhappy with the response, you can complain to the Information Commissioner’s Office.

Why it matters

Electronic records were meant to make care safer and faster, and mostly they do. But a system in which thousands of people can open a file with a click relies on audit trails being checked and consequences being real. The ICO deadline on 27 November will show how many health leaders are prepared to put their names to that promise. Questions about who sees our personal data, and on what grounds, are not confined to the NHS: they also run through the DWP’s use of AI in Universal Credit reviews.