Power

Elbridge Colby: the Pentagon hawk who just infuriated Europe

Elbridge Colby's criticism of Ukraine's long-range strikes at NATO drew rebukes from Wes Streeting and Boris Pistorius. Here is what he said and why it matters.

Elbridge Colby, the Pentagon’s under secretary for policy and the intellectual architect of the Trump administration’s defence strategy, is in the news this week because of what he told Ukraine’s allies in Brussels on Tuesday 17 November. At a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters, he argued that some of Kyiv’s long-range strikes inside Russia were doing little to change the course of the war. Britain’s Defence Secretary, Wes Streeting, and Germany’s Boris Pistorius both publicly disagreed, and The Telegraph reported that Colby left the meeting early.

Empty chair at a NATO meeting table, illustrating the Elbridge Colby row over Ukraine's long-range strikes

The episode landed in the same week that Ukraine brought down part of the Kerch bridge, which is precisely the kind of deep strike Colby was questioning. It also comes a fortnight before Washington is due to finish a review that could reduce the number of American troops stationed in Europe.

What did Elbridge Colby say about Ukraine?

According to Stars and Stripes, Colby said certain Ukrainian strikes inside Russia were doing little to slow Moscow’s advances or bring the war closer to an end. Attacks on civilian infrastructure, he argued, “have actually probably hardened the Russian public’s resolve”. He was careful to add that Ukraine should not have to fight with its “hands tied behind its back”, but said Kyiv’s strikes should concentrate on military targets.

The critique arrived as Ukraine’s defence minister, Yevhenii Khmara, was promising the opposite direction of travel. “For every strike they launch against our territory, we will respond twice or three times as forcefully,” Khmara told the meeting, announcing plans to more than triple Ukraine’s deep-strike capability next year.

How did Britain and Germany respond?

Unusually bluntly. Pistorius called Colby’s assessment “quite a stupid thing” to say, arguing that the focus should instead be on Russia’s repeated attacks on Ukraine’s electricity, water and heating. Streeting was more diplomatic but no less clear: “It’s not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war.” He added that the long-range campaign had “helped to degrade Putin’s war machine, buying time and saving lives”, according to the Kyiv Post.

Britain then underlined the point. On Wednesday 18 November the government announced it would give Ukraine more than 1,000 long-range strike drones, which it described as “able to carry heavy warheads capable of flattening targets in a single hit”.

Did Colby walk out of the NATO meeting?

That is how it has been widely described, though the detail comes from anonymous sources. The Telegraph reported on 18 November that Colby left before a classified briefing by Khmara on the effect of Ukraine’s strikes; one source said he departed as journalists were ushered out. The US ambassador to NATO, Matthew Whitaker, represented Washington for the rest of the session. A German source told the paper that “the US was the one nation that was siding with Russia’s narrative”.

Who is Elbridge Colby?

Colby, the grandson of former CIA director William Colby, served in the Pentagon during Donald Trump’s first term and was a principal author of the 2018 National Defense Strategy, which reoriented American planning around competition with China. He returned in 2025 as under secretary of defense for policy, one of the department’s most senior civilian posts, and oversaw the 2026 National Defense Strategy.

His central argument has not changed: America’s resources are finite, China is the priority, and Europe must take “primary responsibility for the conventional defence of Europe”, as he told NATO ministers in February, when he also called the alliance’s current approach “no longer fit for purpose”, Al Jazeera reported. He has been criticised in Washington, too: in September senators from both parties complained that a briefing he gave on the defence strategy failed to provide an expected update.

What did he say about US troops and European arms deals?

The Ukraine row overshadowed two points that matter more to Europe in the long run. Reuters reported that Colby remained hopeful a 1 December deadline would be met for the six-month review of US force posture in Europe that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth launched in June. Roughly 80,000 US troops are based in Europe, about 35,000 of them in Germany. “We’re going to allocate our military where it’s most needed for Americans,” Colby said, naming the Western Hemisphere and the Indo-Pacific, while insisting “that doesn’t mean abandoning Europe”.

He also warned European governments against shutting American companies out as they spend more on defence. “We understand European populations need to benefit from greater defence spending. That’s only fair and reasonable,” he said, before adding that “American companies make the best weaponry in the world” and that a secure Europe in what he called “NATO 3.0” would still need kit such as the F-35. Pistorius said he expected clarity on any US drawdown within weeks: “We expect changes in troop levels, but we don’t know anything concrete yet.”

Why it matters for Britain

For London, the week exposed a gap that ministers usually paper over. The UK has made Ukraine’s long-range strike capability a central part of its support, and Streeting chose to say so in public, standing alongside Germany rather than Washington. At the same time Britain is a major buyer of American equipment, including the F-35, and is exposed to any American rethink on European posture.

The next markers are close. A Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, with US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner expected, was due on Thursday 19 November, and the posture review deadline falls on 1 December. If Colby’s remarks were a preview of Washington’s thinking, Europe will not have to wait long to find out.