Seven weeks after an independent commission found Manchester City guilty of breaking Premier League financial rules on an industrial scale, the case that has hung over English football since February 2023 is approaching its next decisive moment. The verdict, published on 29 September 2026, upheld 114 of the 115 charges. City have appealed, and reports that the appeal will be heard in mid-December have pushed the story firmly back up the agenda. What nobody yet knows is the punishment.

What did the Man City verdict actually decide?
The commission found that City broke the rules across nine seasons, from 2009-10 to 2017-18, a period in which the club won three league titles. According to the league’s published findings, City used what the panel repeatedly called “sham” commercial contracts “to artificially inflate the club’s revenues, and reduce its costs”. Sponsors linked to Abu Dhabi paid only part of the sums recorded, with the rest covered by the owners, Abu Dhabi United Group, through what the commission described as a “disguised funding scheme”.
The numbers are startling. The total distortion to City’s accounts was put at more than £900m, of which more than £830m was secret owner funding presented as sponsorship. NBC Sports, summarising the findings, reported that roughly 87 per cent of the commercial income City declared over the period was not in fact paid by the sponsors. The Press Association added overstated image-rights income of about £74m and understated staff liabilities of about £17m.
The single charge City escaped related to a portion of the non-cooperation counts. On the substance of the financial case, the club lost almost everywhere.
How did City and the Premier League react?
Richard Masters, the Premier League’s chief executive, called it “the most significant” disciplinary case “in Premier League history”, and said the club had “systematically broke[n] Premier League rules for nearly a decade”. City, in turn, declared themselves “disappointed and surprised” and insisted “the Club is innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League”, citing what they call “irrefutable evidence” that the sponsors, not the owners, were funded by the Abu Dhabi government.
The chief executive, Ferran Soriano, went further in a video to staff and players, saying the case rested on “a single false accusation” and that the panel had accepted a Premier League “conspiracy theory”. The commission’s own view of that defence was blunt: it said the government-funding explanation had been “concocted well after the event”.
Outside the two camps, reaction was less nuanced. Tony Pulis, whose Stoke side lost the 2011 FA Cup final to City, told the BBC he did not expect trophies to change hands, adding: “But I still feel cheated.”
When is the Man City appeal?
City lodged their appeal on 1 October, arguing that the commission’s opinion contains “clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe”. Under Premier League rules, it goes to a fresh three-person appeal board, and the hearing should take place within 12 weeks of the appeal being lodged, which points to a finish by Christmas Eve.
The Financial Times reported, as relayed by SPORTbible on 13 November, that the hearing is set for mid-December and is expected to run for “a number of days”. People close to the case were quoted as saying that, if City lose, sanctions would follow early in 2027. The Premier League has said the process will remain private until an outcome can be published, so the precise dates are reported rather than confirmed.
Emanuel Macedo de Medeiros, chief executive of the Sport Integrity Global Alliance, urged patience in an interview with the Press Association, arguing that the outcome “cannot leave room for doubt” and that he expected the case to conclude “sooner rather than later”.
What sanctions could Manchester City face?
This is the part of the story that remains entirely open. Sanctions will be set at a separate private hearing in front of the original commission, and there is no fixed tariff. Rule W64 of the Premier League handbook allows a fine, a points deduction or expulsion, plus a catch-all power to make “such other order as it thinks fit”, which some lawyers argue could in theory extend to stripping titles.
The recent precedents are small by comparison. Everton were docked ten points in 2023, later reduced to six, and Nottingham Forest lost four, both for breaches of the league’s profit and sustainability rules. Kieran Maguire, the football finance academic, has suggested, as Al Jazeera reported, that the panel might “add a zero” to those figures. Several outlets have floated deductions of 40 to 50 points; those are press projections, not anything the league has signalled.
- Confirmed: guilty on 114 charges; appeal lodged 1 October; sanctions to be decided separately.
- Reported: appeal hearing in mid-December; sanctions early 2027 if the appeal fails.
- Speculative: the size of any points deduction, and whether titles are touched.
Why the rest of the league is watching so closely
The case has become as much about governance as about one club. Premier League clubs have voted to indemnify the league’s directors should City’s sponsors bring legal action, a measure that required the backing of at least 14 of the 20 members. Sky Sports has reported that rival clubs do not expect City to remain in the division next season if the appeal fails, though that is a reading of the room rather than a ruling. It is a reminder of how much of modern football’s money and status now depends on the credibility of the rulebook.
City, for their part, retain options beyond the appeal board. As Al Jazeera noted, the Court of Arbitration for Sport is not available to them in a domestic case, but a challenge to the fairness of the process in the High Court in London remains possible. Further inquiries from the FA, the new Independent Football Regulator or tax authorities have also been floated by commentators.
What happens next
Expect very little officially until the appeal board sits in December, then a decision that, under league rules, should arrive within 30 days of the hearing ending. If City win, the case collapses into one of the great legal embarrassments in sport. If they lose, the sanctions hearing begins, and with it a second round of appeals. For a full account of the findings, Al Jazeera’s explainer and NBC Sports’ timeline are the clearest guides. Either way, the season on the pitch is being played under a cloud that may not lift until spring.